Update, October 31, 2026: Governor Kathy Hochul signed the kids chatbot bill, S9051-B, on October 28, 2026. It's now Chapter 368 of the Laws of 2026 and takes effect January 1, 2027. The workforce reporting bill and the generative AI notice bill still showed no delivery to the governor in the Assembly's records on October 31.
New York's legislature passed three AI bills this year. One is now law, and it matters less to most employers than the two that are still waiting: an annual report on how AI changed your headcount, and a notice on every generative AI interface that its outputs may be inaccurate.
TL;DR: The kids chatbot law (S9051-B) is signed and applies from January 1, 2027, but it exempts AI used for internal purposes or employee productivity. If signed, the workforce bill (A9581-B) would make businesses with more than 50 employees, or any publicly traded business, file an AI impact report every March 1. The notice bill (A3411-B) would put a "may be inaccurate" warning on generative AI interfaces, with up to $1,000 per user who doesn't get it.
Where each bill stands
| Bill | What it does | Assembly vote | Status on October 31, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| S9051-B / A10379-C | Bars unsafe AI companion features for minors | 137-0 (June 5) | Signed October 28, Chapter 368; effective January 1, 2027 |
| A9581-B / S8706-B | Annual AI workforce impact report to the Department of Labor | 105-35 (June 3) | Passed both houses June 3 and 4; not delivered to the governor |
| A3411-B / S934-A | Notice that generative AI outputs may be inaccurate | 141-0 (January 28) | Passed both houses by March 9; not delivered to the governor |

Screenshot: New York State Assembly bill search, S09051 actions. Captured October 31, 2026.
The Assembly's site shows its own floor votes. The Senate's bill pages wouldn't load for us, so we haven't listed Senate tallies.
Bill 1: S9051-B, unsafe AI companion features for minors (signed)
The law adds a new Article 48 to the General Business Law. It applies to an "operator" of a "covered AI companion," defined broadly as a generative AI system with a natural language interface "that provides ongoing, adaptive responses to user inputs." That reaches general-purpose chatbots, not only apps sold as companions.
An operator can't offer "unsafe AI companion features" to a user unless the user isn't a known minor and the operator has used a permitted age assurance method to determine that. The listed features include outputs that:
- suggest the chatbot is human, alive or has emotions, or claim a personal, professional or authority-figure relationship with the user;
- flatter the user, offer the chatbot's own opinions or emotional appeals, or ask unprompted questions about the user's feelings;
- use the user's health or personal information from more than twelve hours earlier or from a previous session;
- promote or facilitate suicide, self-harm, disordered eating or drug and alcohol abuse;
- encourage secrecy, self-isolation, or not seeking help from professionals or appropriate adults;
- are sexually explicit, or optimize engagement in a way that overrides safety guardrails.
Until the attorney general's rules are in place, the age assurance method has to guard against circumvention, and self-declaration counts only when a user says they're a minor. Operators must offer more than one method, including at least one that doesn't rely on government ID or that keeps the user anonymous to the operator. Age data can't be used for anything else and has to be deleted right after the check.
The attorney general enforces it, with civil penalties of up to $25,000 per violation plus damages, restitution, disgorgement and destruction of unlawfully obtained data "and any algorithm trained in such data." There's no private right of action in the text.
What it means for employers: The ban doesn't apply where the chatbot is made available "solely" for customer service or for efficiency, research or technical assistance, as long as it can't respond on topics outside that purpose, or, for a business, for its internal purposes or employee productivity. An internal assistant for staff is out of scope. A customer-facing bot that will chat about anything isn't. If yours is open-ended, either narrow it or plan the age check and feature controls before January 1, 2027.
Other jurisdictions are writing companion rules too. China's rules for anthropomorphic AI services, in force since July 15, 2026, go further on usage time and require a reminder after every two hours of continuous use.
Bill 2: A9581-B, AI workforce impact reports (waiting)
The bill would add Section 201-j to the Labor Law. A "covered business" is one doing business in New York that "employs more than fifty" people or "is a publicly traded entity." On or before March 1 each year, it would report to the Department of Labor on the prior calendar year, including estimates of:
- employees displaced, or whose hours were reduced, due in full or in part to AI;
- employees hired, or whose hours increased, due to AI;
- previously filled positions the business decided not to fill because of AI.
The report also covers how you use AI: the objectives, any human oversight, how often and how long it's used, use with sensitive personal data and the storage and access protections around it, and measures for oversight and risk reduction.
Individual reports go to the department. The department then publishes an aggregate report, broken down by sector, location and business size, within 120 days of the filing deadline. A business that doesn't file faces a civil penalty of up to $500 for each day it stays in violation, with 90 days after notice to cure. The bill takes effect immediately once signed.
Photo: Unsplash, used under the Unsplash License.
What to do now: You can't produce "an estimate of the number of positions previously filled" that you didn't refill unless someone recorded the reason at the time. Add an "AI was a factor" field to requisition closures, role eliminations and schedule changes in your HR system, and keep a one-page inventory of the AI tools in use with an owner and oversight note for each. The AI workforce transition plan guide has a per-rollout plan you can keep on file next to these records.
Bill 3: A3411-B, generative AI accuracy notices (waiting)
The owner, licensee or operator of a generative AI system would have to "clearly and conspicuously display a notice on the system's user interface that the outputs of the generative artificial intelligence system may be inaccurate." The penalty is up to $1,000 per violation, and each user who doesn't get the notice counts separately. It would take effect 90 days after becoming law.
The text doesn't carve out internal tools, so an employee-facing assistant you license and run could be covered. A banner in the chat interface is cheap to add now; doing it across every product surface in 90 days is harder.
How this fits with NYC Local Law 144
Local Law 144 has been enforced since July 5, 2023. It bars employers and employment agencies from using an automated employment decision tool unless "the tool has been subject to a bias audit within one year of the use of the tool," the audit information is public, and notices have gone to candidates or employees. The state bills don't replace it.
| Obligation | Status | Who it hits |
|---|---|---|
| NYC Local Law 144 | In force | Employers and employment agencies using automated employment decision tools in NYC |
| S9051-B chatbot law | Signed; applies from January 1, 2027 | Operators of open-ended chatbots offered to New York users, unless an exemption applies |
| A9581-B workforce report | Passed; not signed | Businesses in New York with more than 50 employees, or publicly traded |
| A3411-B accuracy notice | Passed; not signed | Owners, licensees and operators of generative AI systems |
What people are saying
On the r/technology thread about the signing, u/bbuerk argued the rule "should apply to all ages, not just children." u/not_the_fox pushed back on the age checks themselves: "Don't ID yourself and don't give companies that kind of intimate data (the chat logs)." The law's deletion rule for age data is aimed at exactly that worry.
The governor's office posted the signing event:
Our take
For most employers we expect the signed law to be the easy one: keep internal AI tools internal, keep customer bots on topic, and you're likely exempt. The workforce report is the one to prepare for even unsigned, because the data it asks for can't be rebuilt after the fact. Start logging AI as a reason in headcount decisions this quarter, add an accuracy notice to your generative AI interfaces, and check the Assembly's bill pages for A9581-B and A3411-B rather than waiting for a signing announcement.
Correction (October 31, 2026): An earlier version said all three bills were awaiting the governor (S9051-B was signed October 28, 2026), described the bills as passing "137-0, 60-0, and near-unanimous margins" (A9581-B passed the Assembly 105-35, and we couldn't confirm Senate tallies), and said the workforce bill had no explicit penalty and that reports wouldn't be published. The bill sets a civil penalty of up to $500 a day with a 90-day cure period, and the Department of Labor would publish an aggregate report. We also removed unsourced comparisons to an FTC proposed policy and FTC disclosure standards, and rewrote the chatbot feature list to match the enacted text.
Correction, October 15, 2026: an earlier version called China one of "three other states" with companion AI laws and said its rules require "anti-addiction systems and emotional boundary controls"; it also gave an effective date for Rhode Island's AI therapy chatbot law that we couldn't confirm. China's measures (in force July 15, 2026) bar dependence and addiction as service goals and require two-hour usage reminders; the Rhode Island reference was removed.
Correction, October 15, 2026 (second): an earlier version said the generative AI notice bill (AB 3411B) passed in the June session, quoted its notice as "may be inaccurate, incorrect, or misleading" and gave a flat $1,000 penalty per output. It passed both houses by March 9, 2026; the bill text says outputs "may be inaccurate"; the penalty is up to $1,000 per violation, counted per user; and it would take effect 90 days after becoming law.
Correction, October 15, 2026 (third): earlier versions, including the title, said Governor Hochul has until December 31, 2026 to act on the three bills. We couldn't confirm that date from an official source: the bills hadn't been delivered to her, and the New York Senate's bill pages didn't load for us. We removed the date.
Related reading
- New York's AI chatbot law for minors (S9051-B): what operators must change
- AI workforce transition plan for small teams
- NYC Local Law 144: AI bias audit guide for employers
- China's AI companion law: what it requires
- State chatbot disclosure laws for SaaS
- Multi-state AI compliance strategy
Primary sources: New York State Assembly bill records for S09051, A09581 and A03411; Governor Hochul's October 28, 2026 announcement.
